Melt the days away with these extra cheesy menu ideas

By Liz Barrett Foster

We’ve always used cheesy foods to make ourselves feel better, whether it’s a gooey grilled cheese paired with chicken noodle soup to help a cold go away faster, or a big cheese pizza after a hard work week. Now we’re all living through a global pandemic. As everyone looks for small and simple ways to boost their moods (even if just temporarily), consumers are craving — and seeking out — familiar foods that drum up feelings of warmth and comfort. Here, we explore a few new ways to integrate the comforting vibe of melted cheese into your menu.

Making Cheese Melt

It’s true that most cheeses will melt, if they get warm enough. However, there’s a scientific reason why some cheeses melt easily while others hold their structure long after hitting the heat.

The act of melting cheese is a delicate balance between moisture, age and acid content, according to Chef Chris Bugher, CEC (opposite), chef-instructor of culinary arts at Asheville-Buncombe Technical Community College in Asheville, North Carolina. “A really, really fresh cheese can melt decently, but it can also curdle,” he says. “A young cheese is probably the best for melting. An aged cheese can melt, but it can be tough, because the protein structure is so tight due to moisture loss.”

Another factor in how well a cheese melts has to do with acidulation, according to Chef Bugher, which occurs when an acid element is added to a cheese. “Animal rennet melts really well, but if you add acid to cheese, it interferes with the denaturing process of the proteins,” he says. “So, for example, a cheese like feta, which is brined, won’t melt very well.”

Chris Bugher headshot
Chef Chris Bugher, CEC.

Whichever cheese you choose to melt, Chef Bugher suggests opting for a low-and-slow method over cooking cheese too quickly, which can extract the butterfat too soon. “Take a little bit of cornstarch and mix that with white wine as a base before you even start [melting],” he says. “It’s a version of the slurry that creates a traditional Swiss fondue.”

If you’re in a pinch and need to melt cheese fast without making a fondue base or using the traditional two-to-three-minutes-under-the-broiler method, Chef Dave Woolley, “director of deliciousness” for Atlanta-based Buffalo Wild Wings, says that he regularly uses a Searzall, a blowtorch attachment that diffuses the flame and helps cheese melt quickly and efficiently.

Newly Trendy Cheeses

Cheddar and mozzarella have been the go-to melting cheeses for decades, but with so many cheeses to choose from now, chefs are getting more adventurous in their offerings.

Chef Bugher says he’s seeing a resurgence of Swiss raclette (which means “to scrape” in French), a traditional Alpine cheese that is usually served over pickled vegetables and potatoes. Just before the pandemic hit last year, social media feeds were flooded with videos showing wheels of raclette on heat lamps being scraped onto the plates of awestruck customers.

Melted cheese raclette at a french fair
Melted cheese raclette at a french fair market

Anne Hoyt, cheesemaker and co-owner of Leelanau Cheese, in Suttons Bay, Michigan, makes Swiss raclette, and points out that French and Swiss raclettes are two very different cheeses. The French raclette, which is what most retailers in the U.S. sell, is used almost exclusively for melting, due to its softness and pungency, according to Hoyt. The Swiss raclette is sweeter and more versatile, able to be melted or sliced for a variety of menu applications. “I like to say that Swiss raclette has the consistency of Gouda and the nuttiness of Gruyere,” she says.

Blue cheeses, such as Roquefort, are becoming popular to melt over eggs, steak or potatoes. “I like to crumble Roquefort cheese over skillet-fried potatoes and onions and serve that alongside a steak,” Chef Woolley says. “The Roquefort starts to melt, but not all the way, and it tastes great over the potatoes.”

Sometimes, cheese blends are the way to go. Chef Woolley says he’ll create a traditional mac and cheese with Monterey Jack, mozzarella and cheddar, and then grate nontraditional cheeses, such as raclette, on top to create different layers of flavor.

This article originally appeared in the January/February 2021 issue of National Culinary Review. Click here to download the full issue.